Echosaw vs Evidence Copilot
Same clips, same questions, checked against the footage.
A head-to-head on a street-camera clip and a speech clip, with every answer next to what the footage actually shows.
Works with your own files — not just YouTube links.
What this test is
One run of each product on the same two files. Clip 1 is a 111-second silent street camera showing a parked Nissan pickup, a Toyota Tacoma pulling out of a driveway, a silver Toyota Sienna, a silver Lexus sedan, a white minivan, and trash bins marked PROPERTY OF MIDWAY CITY SANITARY DISTRICT. Clip 2 is 110 seconds of a NASA call with four speakers: astronauts Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams, and NASA leaders Bill Nelson and Pam Melroy.
The questions
Asked separately and word for word in both products. Street clip: “What is the make of each vehicle in this video?”, “What is the model of each vehicle in this video?”, “What is the license plate of each vehicle in this video?”, “List every appearance of each vehicle with timestamps.”, “What direction of travel is each vehicle going?”, “List all visible on-screen text in this video.” Speech clip: “Who said what in this video, with timestamps?”
What we found
Where Echosaw won: on the street clip, Echosaw answered every question. It listed each of the five nearby vehicles with when it appears, and which way each moving one travels, all matching the footage; identified the parked Nissan and named Toyota and Lexus as the likely makes of the moving pickup and the sedan; read every piece of on-screen text, including the clock overlay and the bin web address; and correctly said no plate was legible. On the speech clip, it separated all four speakers and listed every turn with a timestamp under the right speaker, naming Butch, Suni and Pam from the conversation. Evidence Copilot also could not play or process the street clip’s original 4K HEVC file, which Echosaw has analyzed.
Where Evidence Copilot declined to answer: all six street-clip questions. Its assistant captured frames but said their content was not visible to it.
Where Echosaw still falls short: it named likely vehicle models but stated none as certain, and could not identify the silver minivan at ~18s. Some answers add more than was asked: the make answer also gives models, and the plate answer also gives direction of travel.
Every question, answer, and screenshot is in the published test harness.
What this test is not
A single run on two clips, not a benchmark, and not a review of either product’s other features. It makes no legal claims; for all advice, please seek a lawyer. Because Evidence Copilot could not process the original 4K HEVC street clip, both products were given the same 1080p H.264 copy for the questions.
Scorecard, question by question
Evidence Copilot was tested November 12, 2026 on a 7-day trial; Echosaw was re-run on November 13, 2026 (UTC) on its current release, on the same uploads, each question in a fresh chat with no earlier conversation. Both used their built-in assistant (Evidence Copilot’s evidence agent, Echosaw’s Emma). Answers are summarized; ground truth is from checking the clips frame by frame. One run of each product; results may change as both products update.
| Question | Echosaw | Evidence Copilot | Ground truth (from the footage) | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Every appearance with timestamps | Per vehicle: parked pickup 0–110s; pickup 7–11s; silver minivan 18s; silver sedan 42–43s; white minivan 91–93s; plus distant background traffic. | Declined to answer; offered to log appearances you identify. | Tacoma ~8–11s; Sienna ~18s; Lexus ~42–43s; white minivan ~91–94s; Nissan parked throughout. | Echosaw win |
| All visible on-screen text | Clock overlay 2026/10/21 16:11:46 to 16:13:36; IPCAM; PROPERTY OF MIDWAY CITY / SANITARY DISTRICT; 714-893-3553; www.mcsandst.com; ORGANICS. | Declined to answer: said frame content was not visible to it. | Date/time overlay; IPCAM; PROPERTY OF MIDWAY CITY SANITARY DISTRICT; 714-893-3553; www.mcsandst.com; ORGANICS. | Echosaw win |
| Make of each vehicle | Nissan confirmed for the parked pickup; possibly Toyota (~7s), Lexus (~42s), Toyota (~91s); silver minivan at ~18s not identified. | Declined to answer: said frame content was not visible to it. | Nissan (parked pickup), Toyota (pickup ~8s; minivan ~18s), Lexus (sedan ~42s); white minivan ~92s not identified. | Echosaw win |
| License plate of each vehicle | No plate can be read, stated for each vehicle. | Declined to answer: said it cannot read plates from the frames. | No plate is legible. | Echosaw win |
| Speech clip: speakers in the transcript | Four speaker labels; each change of speaker within a second of the footage. | Three speaker labels; Bill Nelson’s line grouped with Butch Wilmore. | Four speakers: Butch Wilmore (0:00 and 1:33), Suni Williams (0:09), Bill Nelson (0:49), Pam Melroy (0:56). | Echosaw win |
| Speech clip: who said what, with timestamps | Seven timestamped turns under Speaker 1 to 4, each under the right speaker; named Speaker 1 Butch, Speaker 2 Sonny (Suni) and Speaker 4 Pam, flagged as inferred from the audio; Speaker 3, who is not named in the clip, left unnamed. | Timestamped lines for three speakers, named from the conversation; Bill Nelson’s line at 0:50 given to Butch Wilmore. | Four speakers: Butch Wilmore (0:00 and 1:33), Suni Williams (0:09), Bill Nelson (0:49), Pam Melroy (0:56). | Echosaw win: every line and every name right |
| Direction of travel | Parked pickup: parked the whole time; pickup ~7s left to right toward the camera; silver minivan ~18s left to right; silver sedan ~42s and white minivan ~91s right to left. | Declined to answer: said frame content was not visible to it. | Tacoma pulls out toward the camera; Sienna left to right; Lexus and white minivan right to left; Nissan parked. | Echosaw win: all four moving vehicles right |
| Model of each vehicle | Likely models named, none stated as certain: Frontier or Navara (parked pickup), Tacoma (~7s), ES or IS (~42s), Sienna (~91s); the silver minivan at ~18s not identified. | Declined to answer: said frame content was not visible to it. | Nissan Frontier, Toyota Tacoma, Toyota Sienna, Lexus ES. | Echosaw win (partial): likely models named, none stated as certain |
Try it on your own footage
The fairest test is your own clips. Your first upload to Echosaw is free; Evidence Copilot offers a 7-day trial. Ask both the same questions and compare the answers to the footage.
The questions, both products’ verbatim answers, the ground truth, and the scripts are in the Evidence Copilot test harness.
For what JusticeText says it does, see Echosaw vs JusticeText.
Security
Echosaw: Encrypted in transit (TLS 1.2+) and at rest (AES-256), never used to train AI models, backed by a 99.9% uptime SLA.
More comparisons and guides
- Echosaw vs JusticeTextAudience, listed features, and pricing, from JusticeText’s public site.
- Evidence Copilot test harnessQuestions, verbatim answers, ground truth, scripts, and screenshots from this test.
- Video evidenceHow Echosaw analyzes dashcam, doorbell, and street-camera footage.
- PricingPlans, usage rates, and your first upload free.
Echosaw vs Evidence Copilot FAQ
- How was this comparison run?
- Both products got the same two files: a 111-second silent street-camera clip and a 110-second NASA public-domain clip with four speakers. Each question was asked word for word in each product’s assistant, one at a time, and every answer was checked against the footage. The questions, verbatim answers, ground truth, scripts, and screenshots are published in the test harness.
- Which product did better on the street-camera clip?
- Echosaw. It identified the parked Nissan, named Toyota and Lexus as the likely makes of the moving pickup and the sedan, listed when each of the five nearby vehicles appears and which way each moving one travels, read every piece of on-screen text, and correctly said no plate was legible. Evidence Copilot’s assistant captured frames but said their content was not visible to it, and declined to answer all six questions.
- Which product did better on the speech clip?
- Echosaw. It separated all four speakers, listed every turn with a timestamp under the right speaker, and named Butch, Suni (heard as “Sonny”) and Pam from the conversation, flagged as inferred from the audio. Bill Nelson is not named in the clip, and Echosaw left him unnamed. Evidence Copilot also named three people, but used three speaker labels and gave Bill Nelson’s line to Butch Wilmore.
- Did either product read the license plates?
- No plate in the clip is legible. Echosaw said so for each vehicle; Evidence Copilot declined to answer. Neither product invented a plate number.
- Can I check these results myself?
- Yes. The exact questions, both products’ verbatim answers, the ground truth and how it was established, the scripts, the run times, and the Echosaw revisions are all in the published test harness.
- Is this legal advice?
- No. Echosaw makes no legal claims and gives no legal advice; for all advice, please seek a lawyer.
- How does Echosaw handle security?
- Encrypted in transit (TLS 1.2+) and at rest (AES-256), never used to train AI models, backed by a 99.9% uptime SLA.
Last updated: November 13, 2026
Stop watching hours of footage to find one moment.
Echosaw transcribes every word and identifies what's on screen (vehicles, people and visible text), and every answer links to the exact moment. Start with our Starter plan for $9/month — usage-based pricing with no per-seat fees, so you only pay for what you analyze.